Search
 
Write
 
Forums
 
Login
"Let there arise out of you a band of people inviting to all that is good enjoining what is right and forbidding what is wrong; they are the ones to attain felicity".
(surah Al-Imran,ayat-104)
 
 Views: 2634   
 Replies: 12   
 Share with Friend  
 Post Comment  
http://www.dawn. com/2008/ 06/24/op. htm#1

Swat after the peace deal

By Khadim Hussain

AFTER the government of NWFP signed a peace deal with the hardliner militants of Maulana Fazlullah in Swat on May 21, the enlightened population of Swat believed that the situation in the scenic valley would normalise within a short span of time.

Under the deal, the government and the hardliner Fazlullah's militia had agreed that Sharia law would be imposed, the Pakistan army would gradually withdraw, the government and the Taliban would exchange prisoners, the Taliban would recognise the writ of the government, halt attacks on barber shops and music shops. The Taliban will not operate training camps, a ban would be placed on raising private militias, the Taliban would turn in heavy weapons, denounce suicide attacks and would cooperate in vaccination drives. Mamderhai Markaz of Fazlullah would be turned into an Islamic University and the Taliban would allow women to perform their duties in their workplace
without fear.

Irrespective of how the deal was portrayed in the western, Indian and Afghan media, not to speak of the American corporate media, unstructured interviews with a cross-section of the population from different parts of Swat depict two apparently contradictory
scenarios. It seems a majority of the population in Swat has already formed its own opinion about the deal almost a month after it was signed by the NWFP government apparently with the consent of the federal government.

The first scenario: the urban centres are open, suicide bombing has stopped, mobility of people in the towns has increased but very little business activity is taking place. "Hotels have recorded a loss of Rs3bn since May 2007 in the length and breadth of Swat. If
you assume that a tourist spends ten times more than what he/she spends on his boarding, the figure for the loss suffered by only the tourism industry goes up to Rs30bn," says Zahid Khan, President, All Swat Hotels Association. Khan doubts if there will be a revival of the industry considering the vulnerable security situation caused by
the confrontation between the Taliban and the security forces.

The second scenario: the Taliban have strong control over the upper parts of Swat and some parts of Kabal. They continue to hold trials for trivial disputes in a village of Matta called Budegram while the complicated disputes among the people are transferred to Peochar, the present headquarters of the hardliner militia of Maulana Fazlullah.

The Taliban continue running training camps in the maze of interlinked hills of Shaur-Peochar- Deolai and then to Khal, Dir "” a district neighbouring Swat, where they have recently been reported to have burnt a few schools for girls. These days one hears more of Syed Agha, a Taliban commander and trainer of Afghan origin, and Bakht Farzand Khan, the reported governor of Matta of the Taliban militia, more than Muslim Khan and Ali Bakht who represented the Fazlullah militia in talks with the provincial government.

The Taliban in the meanwhile have been instrumental in stopping the deforestation in the hills of Sakhra and have exhorted the local population of Bamakhela, a village in Matta, to construct a proper drainage system. They had even initiated the distribution of the
hills of Sambat, previously claimed by the local Khans, among the landless population of the village, but just fell short of implementing their system of redistribution. The Taliban seem to have replaced the local Khans in dispensing speedy justice to the landless
population of the area.

In upper Swat, the local elite have yet to claim their captured orchards. The locals claim that the Taliban stay in those orchards in the day time and climb the hills in the night. There is strong indication that even the male civilian functionaries of the government are yet to resume their regular duties. Matta, Sambat, Namal, Nokhara, Shaur, Pecochar in upper Swat and some parts of Kabal are actually being governed by the Taliban.

All the principles of social interaction and individual behaviour in these areas are expected to be observed according to the Salafi code of Islam. Some locals are of the opinion that the Taliban are also involved in cutting trees and bringing them down to the lower parts of Swat in connivance with the local forestry department. In the rest
of the valley, most of the people seem to be confused about who the real governors are in their region.

The provincial government had assumed that it would be able to break up alliances and networks within the Taliban Salafi jihadist organisations. Evidence on the other hand shows that the Taliban networks are capable of breaking up alliances in the government. The recent controversy between the provincial and central governments amply proves the point.

Some local analysts point out even a more sinister aspect of this story of peace and peace deals. Keeping in view the common perception of the people about the presence of men of Jaish-i-Mohammad and Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan in Swat valley, they believe that the peace deals might give an open space to militants of all hues and
cries to expand their bases.

The result of this process would be an attack from the US either directly or through the Afghan government. This, if it happens, will undoubtedly lead to the disintegration of certain areas from mainstream Pakistan as well as from the mainstream Pashtun belt. This proposition may look far-fetched but keeping in view the recent attacks by the US drones in the border regions of Pakistan and the aggressive comments by Afghan president, Hamid Karzai, one is tempted to take this analysis seriously.

Some observers in Swat believe that civil society organisations, political activists, professionals and middle class businessmen have to start working with confidence. They suggest that the huge loss the people have incurred due to the high intensity conflict in the last two years, damage done to infrastructure, especially residential places, schools and hospitals, frequent power cuts and skyrocketing prices have made the lives of the common people in Swat miserable.

In the recently announced central and provincial budgets, no consideration appears to have been given to the affected areas of Fata and NWFP, especially the scenic Swat valley. A $4bn peace plan by the provincial government that we heard of last month in a section of the press seems to have either been shelved or put on the back burner.

The general impression one gets from observing the situation on the ground is that if the deal was meant to obtain a temporary respite from suicide attacks and attacks on government installations, the objective has apparently been achieved. On all other counts, the implementation of the deal seems to have run into serious trouble.

The writer is a coordinator for Aryana Institute for Regional Research and Advocacy.

Khadim.2005@ gmail.com
 Reply:   Osama & Al-Qaeda are the real
Replied by(invite2truth) Replied on (30/Jun/2008)

Osama & Al-Qaeda are the real cause of all the problems in NWFP+FATA+Afghanistan

 

You wrote "War is imposed on them not by them. I don't defend Osama and Alqaeda, so you are free to talk about them"

 

My dear "Supposed Islamic Scholar" Osama & Al-Qaeda are the real cause of all the problems in NWFP+FATA+Afghanistan. Unfortunately you do not want to discuss them "very strange" isn't it? This is what I mean when I say that stupid & uneducated Muslims like you cannot see farther than your nose. As there is a saying "if you lose money you can make it another day but if you lose your sense of right and wrong than you lose everything". Example of such people is the case of Saddam Hussein, Osama, and stupid people supporting the "Jahil Talebans" like you.

 

By the way tell me how much do you know about the Talebans, do you know their history? How many groups are there? What are the legal & illegal businesses going around there? How much is the volume/turnover (in Millions of US$) for the legal & illegal trades?

 

 

 You wrote "You didn't tell me, where i tried to impose my way of Islam please in your next reply point out the exact portion of my reply :)

 

I wrote : As for my Actions whether I am following Islam properly or not is none of your business, ALLAH (SWT) is sufficient to take account from each and everybody.

 

You Wrote "Yes, i am no one to ask you about your deeds, but if you commit some illegal act in front of me, and i got enough strength to stop you, inshahAllah i will do that, yes indeed Allah is sufficient for all of us

 

I am asking you; who gave you the authority to take law into your hand; Islam is a civilized religion in an Islamic Society consist of law enforcers, scholars, educators, etc; etc; each one has to do their part; NOT THAT EVERY TOM, DICKEN & HARRY TAKES A STICK AND STARTS TO BEAT WHOSOEVER THEY SEE OR FEEL IS DOING WRONG THINGS. THIS IS JAHALAT & ISLAM HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH IT. 

 

By the way why don't you go to the West (and of course the East as well) as there are many wrong things being done, human beings are living like animal; i.e. men & women are living together without marriage and even having children without marriage. Can you change that! Through your "Jahalat" ways or do we need to ponder how to face these challenges and approach each problem with wisdom by telling people about the "True word of Allah (SWT) through Quran i.e. what is right and what is wrong and what is the reward for right & punishment for wrong"

 

Can you tell me how many people reverted to Islam as a result of kidnapping and confinement to by the "Jahil" students of the "Lal Masjid.

 

I Wrote: Whatever I have written is according to Quran & Proper Hadith; however you have failed to met my challenge "TELL ME AN INCIDENCE WHEN OUR GREAT PROPHET MOHAMMAD (PBUH) DID ANYTHING SIMILAR TO WHAT THE BLOODY MURDEROUS TALEBAN & AL-QAEDA OF TODAY ARE DOING"

You Wrote: Holy prophet (PBUH) always ordered to find against those who are in fight with Muslims, fatah-e-makkah is an example of it. Holy Prophet(PBUH) always ordered to defend ourselves, and defend outside aggression, i really couldn't understand what kind of action you want me to justify or clarify.  No one can answer the ridiculous question asked by people like you, one day you will be asking one thing and next day other.

 

My Question is very clear, if your pea brain is unable to understand it please ask some knowledgeable person, or are you living with in a group of Jahils?

 

Now I will make things more clear for you:

Did our Great Prophet ever cut the throat of any enemy publicly?

Did our Great Prophet ever stopped the girls from studying?

Did our Great Prophet ever killed and any innocent person (male/female or child)?

Did our Great Prophet ever advised any Muslim for Suicide?

 

ARE YOU STILL ADAMANT & UNASHAMED FOR SUPPORTING THE JAHIL TALABANS?

 

You wrote: According to belief of a Muslim, Food is from God, and one should not live for food only, one can make good money by making his women prostitute, so should every man let her women go out for prostitution by saying the argument that first i will make myself economically strong and then i will follow the teachings and moral values. Iqbal never give those teachings which you are saying.

 

I cannot Imagine you could come this level of cheapness, of all the legal ways in this world to make right "Halal Risk" you choose the most illegal & disliked profession; well this shows your mental capability; people like you have no choice but to trumpet for the Jahil Talebans.

 

My last advise to you is to please study the Quran & Sunnah with a clean and clear heart, don't study the Quran with heart full of disease; try to remember our Creator & Learn Quran so as to be a knowledgeable Muslim & so as to really understand the Laws of "ALLAH (SWT) and so as not to make "Jusbati"  decisions.

 

All Talebans are not the same; those who are really knowledgeable about Islam detest the general behaviors of their ill educated and greedy colleagues who want to exploit religion for selfish monetary benefits.

 

Excuse me for using some strong statements; which were necessary to wake you up from the slumber of Jahliyat

 

MAY ALLAH (SWT) GUIDE US ALL TO THE RIGHT PATH AMEEN.

 

 

 


 
 Reply:   Thank you for coming upto expe
Replied by(Noman) Replied on (29/Jun/2008)
.
 very Very Sorry to say : First and foremost shame on you for trying to impose your crooked (deviant) way of Islam on others.
 
You didn't tell me, where i tried to impose my way of Islam please in your next reply point out the exact portion of my reply :)

Whatever I have written is according to Quran & Proper Hadith; however you have failed to met my challenge "TELL ME AN INCIDENCE WHEN OUR GREAT PROPHET MOHAMMAD (PBUH) DID ANYTHING SIMILAR TO WHAT THE BLOODY MURDEROUS TALEBAN & AL-QAEDA OF TODAY ARE DOING"

Holy prophet (PBUH) always ordered to find against those who are in fight with Muslims, fatah-e-makkah is an example of it. Holy Prophet(PBUH) always ordered to defend ourselves, and defend outside aggression, i really couldn't understand what kind of action you want me to justify or clarify.  No one can answer the ridiculous question asked by people like you, one day you will be asking one thing and next day other.
 
Yes the American are very brutal & cruel in their dealing with Muslims all over the world and this is not new, it is already mentioned in the Holy Quran than the Jews & Christians can never be your friend, so my dear "Supposed Islamic Scholar" wake up and try to deal with the real situation with wisdom, do the Talibaan or Al-Qaeda have enough military might to face the infidels, if not than first make yourself strong economically and militarily; not like the stupid Osama Bin Laden (agent of the Jews) who misguides the Muslims to their destruction at the hands of the infidels.
 
Yes i do agree with you partially, one should prepare himself for fighting to regain the lost land, but for defending the land you don't have to wait, one should try to defend it at every cost, ow stupid people like you cant understand this logic. Now for your understanding i will give you one example.
Let us suppose, some one come to take your land and he is too power full, now you have two options, either you leave the land to him and get back and prepare yourself to regain the land, this decision is wise if you are too confident that you will get away with that. but even if you decide to fight same time, event hen the decision is right and this will be know as bold step. So if there is a case in which there is no way of surrender or run away then one has to fight, Talibaan are facing the same situation.
The situation you said can be consider by Pakistan in a case where they want to fight against India or America, so if Pakistan can sit back neutrally, then one can admit they don't have the resources for fight and they are preparing themselves for it.
Although as a Muslim we should depend only on Allah.
I hope now you might understand my point, just for you i am once again summarizing my point of view, If one is in a situation where he has to fight or die, then one should fight instead of running and being hit in back. If you are in a jungle in front of lion, who wants to eat you and you are bared had, tell me what you will do, will you try to run by keeping in mind that you can't run or you will try to fight even by knowing that chances for winning are less then 1%. Talibaan are doing resistance not aggression. War is imposed on them not by them. I don't defend Osama and Alqaeda, so you are free to talk about them
 
Talibaan are fighting against aggression not for aggression, there is hell of difference in these two things
 
Unfortunately people like cannot farther than your nose; this is the problem i.e. short sightedness; the ones who really care for the Muslims are people like Quaid-e-Azam, Allam Iqbal, Mahathir Mohammad, who always asked Muslim Ummah to make Economic Progress because with economic progress comes the military power. What have your stupid "Taleban & Al-Qaeda" given to the Muslim Ummah except Suicide Bombs, Death, Misery, Blowing up of Grils Schools, CD Shop, Hair Dresser Shop what is this. It is stupid to even think that "Shariah" can be implemented this way; The problem with the uneducated (illiterate) bunch of Muslims is that they think by keeping a beard and saying the "Kalemi" they have authority to impose their crooked way of Islam on others. NO - NO - NO - Sad to say that people like you are failing because in all your action there isn't any Sunnah you are following your vain desires. The saddest thing is that people like you are weakening the Muslim Ummah

According to belief of a Muslim, Food is from God, and one should not live for food only, one can make good money by making his women prostitute, so should every man let her women go out for prostitution by saying the argument that first i will make myself economically strong and then i will follow the teachings and moral values. Iqbal never give those teachings which you are saying.
I think according to you, holy fight of Ahud was a mistake, and i think according to you the holy fight of Hazrat imam hussain r.a was wrong decision as well and what about this saying of Tipu sultan
"lion's one day life is better the jackal's 100 years life"
 


Dear WAKE-UP you are living in the real world,
same for you brother

MAY ALLAH (SWT) GUIDE US TO THE RIGHT PATH; AMEEN
 
 Reply:   Very Ridiculous Reply from "Su
Replied by(invite2truth) Replied on (29/Jun/2008)

Very Very Sorry to say : First and foremost shame on you for trying to impose your crooked (deviant) way of Islam on others.

Whatever I have written is according to Quran & Proper Hadith; however you have failed to met my challenge "TELL ME AN INCIDENCE WHEN OUR GREAT PROPHET MOHAMMAD (PBUH) DID ANYTHING SIMILAR TO WHAT THE BLOODY MURDEROUS TALEBAN & AL-QAEDA OF TODAY ARE DOING"

Yes the American are very brutal & cruel in their dealing with Muslims all over the world and this is not new, it is already mentioned in the Holy Quran than the Jews & Christians can never be your friend, so my dear "Supposed Islamic Scholar" wake up and try to deal with the real situation with wisdom, do the Taleban or Al-Qaeda have enough military might to face the infidels, if not than first make yourself strong economically and militarily; not like the stupid Osama Bin Laden (agent of the Jews) who misguides the Muslims to their destruction at the hands of the infidels. Unfortunately people like cannot farther than your nose; this is the problem i.e. short sightedness; the ones who really care for the Muslims are people like Quaid-e-Azam, Allam Iqbal, Mahathir Mohammad, who always asked Muslim Ummah to make Economic Progress because with economic progress comes the military power. What have your stupid "Taleban & Al-Qaeda" given to the Muslim Ummah except Suicide Bombs, Death, Misery, Blowing up of Grils Schools, CD Shop, Hair Dresser Shop what is this. It is stupid to even think that "Shariah" can be implemented this way;

The problem with the uneducated (illiterate) bunch of Muslims is that they think by keeping a beard and saying the "Kalemi" they have authority to impose their crooked way of Islam on others. NO "“ NO "“ NO - Sad to say that people like you are failing because in all your action there isn't any Sunnah you are following your vain desires. The saddest thing is that people like you are weakening the Muslim Ummah

Dear WAKE-UP you are living in the real world,

MAY ALLAH (SWT) GUIDE US TO THE RIGHT PATH; AMEEN

 
 Reply:   I didn't blame America, i blam
Replied by(Noman) Replied on (28/Jun/2008)
.
O ur Problem is that we think that other people are stupid; Do we know how to behave in our home? how to behave with our neighbours?
There is some problem with people like you,
Dear Brother These are basic Islamic Values, I do not want to coach any about Islam, everything is clear in Quran & Sunnah, as I wrote before pls TELL ME AN INCIDENCE WHEN OUR GREAT PROPHET MOHAMMAD (PBUH) DID ANYTHING SIMILAR TO WHAT THE BLOODY MURDEROUS TALEBAN & AL-QAEDA OF TODAY ARE DOING.
America is bloody murderous, What the hell has happened with you, i am not able to understand, you are such a blind person that i am really feeling wastage of time talking with you, why don't you start thinking from prior then 9/11, before 9/11 there was no aggression by any Muslims, Palestine were fighting with Israel, and other few countries were fighting against American oppression then suddenly 9/11 drama came to stage and then suddenly Bloody America bombed millions of Muslims for no reason, but now in the return Talibaan and those Muslims are fighting with them, an you insane people instead of supporting them as they re fighting for their land, you are supporting America and its dark forces, you should be ashamed of yourself.
 
Don't tell me Taleban and Al-Qaeda are two seperate groups, don't live in fool's paradise. Their actions are well known "Why were two Afghans butchered yesterday, only because they blamed for the death of Al-Qaeda Leaders in FATA (Damadola)
So what, why aimel kaansi or Saddam got hanged , or why criminals got sentence in any country, those Afghani were traitor and every traitor's end is dog's death.
 
As for my Actions whether I am following Islam properly or not is none of your business, ALLAH (SWT) is sufficient to take account from each and everybody.
Yes, i am no one to ask you about your deeds, but if you commit some illegal act in front of me, and i got enough strength to stop you, inshahAllah i will do that, yes indeed Allah is sufficient for all of us.

LASTLY LET ME TELL YOU ABOUT A VERY AUTHENTIC HADITH -OUR GREAT PROPHET MUHAMMAD (PBUH) SAID THAT THERE WILL BE A GROUP OS MUSLIM WHO WILL READ QURRAN BUT WILL NOT BE ABLE TO TAKE BELOW THEIR NECK I.E THEY WILL THE RULING OF THE QURAN RATHER THEY WILL FOLLOW THEIR OWN VAIN DESIRE
 
I think This is 100% about people like you. Because just site back for a while and the think again, what you are preaching and what other group is preaching, if you try t think neutrally then with in few minutes you will be able to understand who is right and who is wrong.
 
Every Muslim's first duty is to practice and protect Islam, are you doing that?
In the Qurran its written, meaning, "Hum nay un kay dilloon pur mohrain luga dee hein", i m really feeling sorry for you and people like you, who can read, who can spread but who can't understand.
 
 
 Reply:   Pls Stop Blaming USA or any ot
Replied by(invite2truth) Replied on (28/Jun/2008)

Our Problem is that we think that other people are stupid; Do we know how to behave in our home? how to behave with our neighbours?
Dear Brother These are basic Islamic Values, I do not want to coach any about Islam, everything is clear in Quran & Sunnah, as I wrote before pls TELL ME AN INCIDENCE WHEN OUR GREAT PROPHET MOHAMMAD (PBUH) DID ANYTHING SIMILAR TO WHAT THE BLOODY MURDEROUS TALEBAN & AL-QAEDA OF TODAY ARE DOING.
Dont tell me Taleban and Al-Qaeda are two seperate groups, don't live in fool's paradise. Their actions are well known "Why were two Afghans butchered yesterday, only because they blamed for the death of Al-Qaeda Leaders in FATA (Damadola)
As for my Actions wether I am following Islam properly or not is none of your business, ALLAH (SWT) is sufficient to take account from each and everybody.
LASTLY LET ME TELL YOU ABOUT A VERY AUTHENTIC HADITH -OUR GREAT PROPHET MUHAMMAD (PBUH) SAID THAT THERE WILL BE A GROUP OS MUSLIM WHO WILL READ QURAN BUT WILL NOT BE ABLE TO TAKE BELOW THEIR NECK I.E THEY WILL THE RULING OF THE QURAN RATHER THEY WILL FOLLOW THEIR OWN VAIN DESIRE
 
 Reply:   I am not trying to impose anyt
Replied by(Noman) Replied on (26/Jun/2008)

I am not trying to tell you my or any one else's definition of Islam, Do you know why the things are getting worse day by day in NWFP+FATA.
There are only two reasons
1-American bombardment, which initially started without any cause and resulted in civilian deaths.
2-The federal/Musharraf government didn't let NWFP government to announce sharia law in NWFP, despite the fact that NWFP assembly voted in that favor.
My bro, what is the only demand of Talibaan or people of NWFP/SWAT, it is to implement the sharia laws, now you tell me what is the harm in it, infect our country built in the name of Islam as well.
And when ever i talked about Talibaan, be clear on one point, i am not talking about Al-Qaeda. Talibaan and AlQaeeda are two different things or in my thinking USA used Alqaeda to target Pakistan, Afghanistan and Talibaan.
And now in the end as you have given so much references from Saudi, then for your attention here is one khutbaa of imam-e-Kaaba, Read khutbaa in this khutbaa he has said that we should jihad against Denmark, now you tell me , as you want to fully follow him, when you are going to do this.
Please don't be selective regarding Islam, either accept it whole or reject it whole.
May Allah guide us all.
 
 Reply:   Talebans of today are "Khwarij
Replied by(invite2truth) Replied on (26/Jun/2008)

Talebans of today are "Khwarij" who kill innocent People because they consider all other Muslims as "Kaafir" if they do not follow their (Taleban's)crooked (deviant) way of practising Islam. These are the same "Khawarij" who martayard Hazarat Umar (RA) & Hazarat Ali(RA).

Hazrat Ali (RA)had ordered to kill these "Khawarij" wherever found.
 
 Reply:   ISLAM is not what you or I say
Replied by(invite2truth) Replied on (26/Jun/2008)

ISLAM is not what you or I say -Everything is very clear in Quran & Hadith- AllAH (SWT) tell us to obey Allah (SWT) & Rasool(PBUH) and those who have authority over us. Today Saudi Arabia declared that their seceret agencies have arrested over 700 deviant (terrorist). The Ulema & Khatibs are all supporting the Government of Saudi Arabia. Even the Imam of Makkah came to Islamabad to appeal to the Mullas of the "Lal Masjid" that whatever they are doing is not according to Quran & Sunnah but unfortunately the fanatics did not listen to him as well.
My dear friend please don'tbe so much juzbati in religious matters ALLAH (SWT) Has instructed us to approach the people of the Book with "best of Manners" & "Wisdom" then why can't we resolve matters between Muslims peacefully.

See for yourself what is going on now in NWFP specially the Swat & Tribal Areas, who doesen't want peace? who invited the Americans to Agfanistan in the first place? if Osama Bin Laden is not an agent of the Jews (or atleast doing the dirty work for them) than why he ran away from Saudi Arabia, than to Sudan and then to Afganistan?
Look at the root cause of things! today 30% of Industries in NWFP are completely Closed who is paying the wages to these jobless people. What benefit have these bloody Taliban Mullas of today given to their own people, except bombs, blood, death & misery is this ISLAM?
Pls OPEN YOURSELF DON'T TAKE SELTER IN THE CAVE OF IGNORANCE PLS SPREAD THE CORRECT MESSAGE OF ISLAM I.E. LOVE, PEACE, BROTHERHOOD, UNCONDITIONAL SUBMISSION TO THE WILL OF ALLAH (SWT),
LASTLY TELL ME AN INCIDENCE WHEN OUR GREAT PROPHET MOHAMMAD (PBUH) DID ANYTHING SIMILAR WHAT THE BLOODY MURDEROUS TALEBAN & AL-QAEDA OF TODAY ARE DOING.

IN SHORT TALEBAN & AL-QAEDA INCLUDING THEIR SUPPORTERS OF TODAY ARE "ZALIM" THUS ALLAH (SWT) DOES NOT GUIDE THE "ZALIM".

YA ALLAH HAVE MERCY ON US - YA ALLAH GUIDE ME AND MY NATION & ALL MUSLIMS

 
 Reply:   Who ever killed by Talibaan is
Replied by(Noman) Replied on (26/Jun/2008)
.
Here is my answer to your points

1-I can't understand how can a Muslim or any person who have some faith in any thing, can't be emotional about that thing.

2-We all should be extremist and emotional about our religion

3-When any one talks about killings of Talibaan then h should not start with his knowledge of history after 9/11, he should go beyond 9/11 and should see 9/11 as well, Talibaan were not killing any one prior to 9/11, Afghanistan was at the brink of stability, but America invaded them, America Killed them ad America enforced them out of the Afghanistan, the America started killing innocent people in FATA, that was the time when Talibaan started their holy war against America and American collaborators.

Our government is American collaborator means they are with the forces who are fighting against Islam, so every Muslims should stand beside those who are fighting for Allah not with those who are fighting against Allah.

Just for your kind attention, Now days may be you can say in Palestine and Iraq Muslims extremist are killing Innocent Jews/others, but one should see why this is happening, i am not justifying the acts of suicide attacks on civilians, but this is war, when America bombed Iraq, Afghanistan, FATA and other, can you tell me how many innocents got killed, what was the ratio of innocents vs fighters in those bombing.

So brother, be on the side of those who are fighting for Allah and give them break instead of others.

in Last, you said Musharraf is from Allah, then may be after few days you will say, Yazeed was right (NaaauzibAllah) and Hazrat Hussain r.a 's fight against him was wrong (NaaauzibAllah) because Yazeed was also appointed by Allah. So, Please don't use Allah's word for misinterpretation.

And as a Muslim we should fight against those who are doing Allah, According to Qurran, We all have contract from Allah to do this and in the end we will be questioned for this, try to read and understand these thing.

"Amur bilmaroof wah nahin unilmumkir" and for nahin unilmunkir has three levels, if you are very good momin, then stop the evil by hand, if your faith is not that much strong then stop the evil by tongue and if you even can't do this means you are too week Muslim then at least think in your heart that the thing is bad.

So now it is totally at our discretion that which way we want to go, or how good Muslim we are.

 
 Reply:   Extremist innovate religion &
Replied by(invite2truth) Replied on (25/Jun/2008)

I can't understand why we are so much emotional & high handedness ("Juzbati") in matters of religion; we muslims are not given the "Contract" by ALLAH(SWT)to go around and start forcing people to follow a certain way of life. Nor was it done by our Great Prophet (PBUH). Our role model is our Great Prophet (PBUH)a Good Muslim should Study his Sunnah (from right sources)& follow it, he never killed an innocent human being.
As for President Musharraf or any ruler of any country a Muslim should know that they are appointed by ALLAH (SWT) (Please see Surah Al-Baqarah Ayat 247)
 
 Reply:   You can martyr Talibaan, but y
Replied by(Noman) Replied on (25/Jun/2008)

You can martyr Talibaan the same way Musharraf martyr LAL masjid or the same way Yazeed martyr Hazrat Hussain r.a.
But Yazeed, Musharraf and any other force are the one's who got defeated even by claiming victory.
Holy Prophet(PBUH) has said meaning "Allah will give the shadow of his Tukht to those who make Friends for Allah and who make enemies for Allah".
So, my brother, earthly you have every right to talk and give judgment about every thing, but the fact will remain the same, the one who preach Islam, the one who jihad for Allah and the one who forbade others from committing crime by force even are not the extremist, they indeed are the real followers.
And in the end InshahAllah they will be the one, who will take over and will be victorious.
 
 Reply:   Insha-Allah Taleban (The Khawa
Replied by(invite2truth) Replied on (25/Jun/2008)

Kindly note that "Salafi" means the rightly guided followers of Islam immediately after the resurrection of Islam. Now a days we are known as "Khalafi" i.e the people comming later in time.

Today nobody can be "Salafi" in the real sense as one has to go back 1400 years to be so. However by ignorance or by hearsay some people call the followers of Islam who try to practise Islam as per the earliest properly guided Muslim as "Salafis".

Nowadays if any person calls himself a "Salafi" than he is not really following the earliest rightly guided Muslims, for they never called themselves "Salafis" for the name given by Allah (SWT) to people of all time who practise correct Islam is Muslim.

"Talaban" as we understand today is murderous group of very voilent people who are pursuing a political goal with a religious cover. These people are "Khawarij" i.e religious extremist (which one finds in almost all the religions of the world) ufortunately we Muslims also have our share of some black sheeps in our midst. Insha-Allah the Goverment & the couregeous people of Pakistan will defeat them.
 
Please send your suggestion/submission to webmaster@makePakistanBetter.com
Long Live Islam and Pakistan
Site is best viewed at 1280*800 resolution